The darkest day in the Christian calendar—Good Friday—paves the way for the most transcendently glorious one—Easter. You can’t have a resurrection without a death, and the death of Jesus of Nazareth was a ghastly one:
It started with his anguish in the Garden
of Gethsemane; Luke tells us that while praying, Jesus sweated blood. This is
actually a thing, hematidrosis, documented in patients who are in severe
anxiety triggered by fear. One of its effects is weakening the skin. In the
case of Jesus, it would have rendered him more likely to lose blood during flogging,
wearing the crown of thorns and other elements of his execution.
The flogging itself not infrequently
killed people: a scourge comprises multiple braided leather thongs with metal
or stone balls woven into them and a hook at the end of each. The former tenderizes
the victim, often breaking bones; the latter rips their flesh. Covering Jesus
with the purple robe and then ripping it off again would have opened his
wounds, causing more blood loss and sending him into hypovolemic shock. This
latter could have caused pericarditis (inflammation of the sac around the
heart) and brought more sharp pain.
Then we get to the actual crucifixion,
which in itself was a brutal method of execution. Arms outstretched to the
side, with hands nailed to the cross-beam, then knees bent and each foot nailed
to the upright. This makes breathing excruciating. We are told that Jesus’
death came relatively quickly—three to six hours—probably as a result of his
weakened systems.
Modern medical investigators believe that he died of cardiac and respiratory shock, and they put paid to the notion that he merely fainted and was taken down from the cross alive, thus rendering the resurrection a hoax. (There's only one documented case of someone surviving a Roman crucifixion; it's from Flavius Josephus, about 70 years after the death of Christ. In that case, the person was taken down from the cross still visibly alive, and then treated for days before being pronounced "survived". Two others were taken down alive, but were too far gone to benefit from medical treatment.)
I’m leaving out all the reality that—had Jesus undergone everything documented (and known to be a part of Roman judicial punishments) but somehow fooled his (professional) executioners before death, he would still have been in no condition to appear three days later, with scars of wounds but otherwise ticketyboo and feeling a bit peckish; not to mention being described as “conquering death”. It would have taken weeks of care to get him upright after that ordeal, which the Son of Man experienced in every excruciating detail.
Well, but as the Christ was on the cross, bleeding out and gasping for a breath, he also carried the weight of human sins, which was why he was born in a stable 33 years before. So our National Poetry Month entry today comes from the Easter portion of Handel’s Messiah. Based on a passage from Isaiah (my favorite Old Testament book), the chorus “Surely He Hath Borne Our Griefs” sums up the day and gives us hope. Here's the Royal Choral Society performing it.
©2025 Bas Bleu